Overrated Goalie

[Hemsky83]

There are many solid goaltenders in the NHL. Some are overrated and some are underrated.

[P.J Stock]

Martin Broduer should be one of the choices!

[Brdwy Blue]

I agree, Broduer sucks.

[Jason Hamilton]

Broduer????:confused:

Whatever, everyone is allowed to have their own opinion....

I voted for Osgood. I'm sorry, I just don't think he as much talent as we are made to believe.

[cASe SenSiTive]

I'm not a big fan of Osgood, but Burke is horrid. The guy had ONE good season back with the Whalers, and has been riding it ever since.

[ken_valyi]

I'd add Brodeur, Chekmanek, Byron Dafoe, and Olaf Kolzig to the list.

My choice would be Brodeur as well, although I think Chekmanek's recent elevation to being the goaltender to lead Philly to the cup places him a solid second.

Cujo over-rated? Dude, you've never seen the Leafs play have you? :rolleyes:

[Darth Xed]

Originally posted by cASe SenSiTive
I'm not a big fan of Osgood, but Burke is horrid. The guy had ONE good season back with the Whalers, and has been riding it ever since.

Ahhh... I don't know... Burke played on really BAD Whaler teams... now that he is in Phoenix, he lead the league, I believe, in save %, and is at or toward the top again this year... I think Burke may go in the UNDERrated catagory rather than OVERrated... :p